A MiddletoWn Staple
Since 1950

Honest food. Familiar faces. Cozy charm that never left.

Welcome to Maddy’s

Maddy’s has been part of Middletown’s fabric for over 70 years. We’re the neighborhood spot where families meet after church, friends catch up over burgers and fries, and travelers stumble into something that feels a lot like home. Our food is made the way you remember it, and the coffee’s always hot.

You’ll find breakfast favorites, classic diner lunches, comfort dinners, and a few surprises (yes, we have taco omelets). The vibe? No frills, just warmth.

COMFORT CLASSICS, MADE RIGHT

COMFORT CLASSICS, MADE RIGHT

From hand-pressed burgers and hearty skillets to crisp salads and cheesy melts, every plate at Maddy’s is made with care.

Our kitchen serves something for everyone—kids, couples, regulars, and first-timers.

We use real maple syrup if you ask for it. And yes, we believe pancakes should have blueberries and walnuts inside.

That’s just how we do it.

A few local favorites:

  • The Big Breakfast

  • Jersey Boardwalk Burger

  • Chicken & Waffles

  • Monte Cristo Panini

  • Chili Cheese Fries

  • Breakfast Quesadilla

  • Gyros, Wraps, and Salads

  • Real Diner Coffee (that doesn’t taste like diner coffee)

Barry P.

“We go to Maddy’s every Sunday… except for vacation and stuff. The food is consistently excellent—and so is the service.”

John

“I visited while traveling. The food was delicious and well-priced. The vibe makes you feel at home in any small town in America.”

Edna S.

“The taco omelet was very yummy, my husband had the meat lover’s skillet. Their coffee is actually good—rare for a diner.”

We’ll Save You a Seat

Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite, settling in with family, or just want a hot coffee and a quiet booth— Maddy’s is ready for you.

We’re not fancy. We’re just real. And that’s why people keep coming back.